Main Case
Source text
舉。風穴垂語云。若立一塵家國興盛。[得之本有]不立一塵家國喪亡。[失之本無]雪竇拈柱杖云。[是立不立]還有同死同生底衲僧麼。[不道無只是少]
従容録 第三十四則 風穴一塵 Source text
Translation
Case: Fengxue gave an instruction, saying,
Fengxue: If a single particle of dust is established, the country flourishes. [Gaining it is inherently present]
If a single particle of dust is not established, the country perishes. [Losing it is inherently absent]
Xuedou held up his staff and said, [Is this establishing or not establishing?]
Xuedou: Are there any monks who die together and live together? [I do not say there are none, only that they are few]
従容録 第三十四則 風穴一塵 Translation
Background
Key Person
Fengxue Yanzhao (風穴延沼): a Zen monk who was active from the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period to the early Northern Song Dynasty, he is known as the Fourth Patriarch and the restorer of the Linji school who built the foundation for its prosperity.
Xuedou Chongxian (雪竇重顕): Xuedou Chongxian (雪竇重顕) is a Zen monk of the Northern Song dynasty.
Wansong Xingxiu (万松行秀): a Zen master active from the late Jin dynasty to the early Yuan dynasty, best known for compiling Shoyoroku (the Book of Serenity).
Timeline
- 従容録 第三十四則 風穴一塵 (風穴一塵): Shoyoroku Case 34: Fengxue's Single Particle of Dust is a koan in which Fengxue shows, "If a single particle of dust is established, the country flourishes. — c. 930–970
- Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox (風穴鉄牛): a koan in which Fengxue Yanzhao presents that "the Mind-seal of the patriarchs is like the working of an iron ox (the truth beyond movement and stillness)," sets a trap of dualistic views by asking "whether to stamp or not to stamp," and severely defeats Elder Lupi, who fell into discursive thought. — c. 930–970
- Shoyoroku (従容録): a collection of Zen Koans. — c. 1223
Key Terms
Zen (禅): a group of Buddhism.
差別 (差別): Differentiation is the diverse particulars and phenomena that arise in endless variety in the phenomenal world.
Emptiness (空): a state where no things exist.
total dynamic function (全機現)
垂語 (垂語): Suigo is the verbal instruction that a master, a senior monk in a position of guidance, gives to a disciple, a practitioner or student.
Originally not a single thing (本来無一物): a concept that there is nothing to attach to.
Commentary
What is Fengxue’s “Single Particle of Dust”?: A trigger for the mind to create differentiation, concepts, words, and phenomena
Now, let us move to the main case. Fengxue gave an instruction (垂語), saying, “If a single particle of dust is established, the country flourishes. If a single particle of dust is not established, the country perishes.”
- A single particle of dust (一塵): The trigger for all differentiation (差別), concepts, words, and phenomena created by the mind.
- The expressions “flourishing” and “perishing”: These take the form of “names, concepts, and words” used for convenience to convey or think about the ultimate truth itself, which is as it is and free from words and forms. Therefore, they do not literally refer to the rise and fall of actual countries.
- Establishing (立): The aspect of differentiation that acknowledges the existence of various phenomena and distinctions in the world where individual differences appear. This is also called the gate of establishment (建立門).
- Not establishing (不立): The aspect of the original state where everything is equal (the real aspect of true equality), which does not allow any view of differentiation or division. This is also called the gate of sweeping away (掃蕩門).
- Flourishing of the country (Establishing a single particle of dust / The story of Taigong Wang): The historical account of Taigong Wang, who was fishing at the Wei River when King Wen of Zhou discovered him. He helped defeat the Yin dynasty and established the great work and flourishing of the Zhou dynasty. This represents the aspect of establishing honor, achievements, and various distinctions and activities in the phenomenal world.
- Perishing of the country (Not establishing a single particle of dust / The story of Boyi and Shuqi): The historical account of Boyi and Shuqi, who admonished King Wu of Zhou against his military campaign. Feeling ashamed to eat the grain of Zhou, they lived in seclusion on Mount Shouyang and starved to death, maintaining absolute purity. This represents the aspect of rejecting all worldly values and differentiation, remaining completely pure and free of any single thing.
What is Fengxue’s True Intention?: Do not lean toward either establishing or not establishing
Here, we must note one thing. An ideal that ignores reality cannot stand. In the same way, reality that ignores an ideal has no progress. Therefore, the Buddha-dharma must not be only the gate of establishment, nor only the gate of sweeping away.
If you reject all phenomena and differentiation and shut yourself only in the purity of “nothingness” (無一物), you will fall into “starving to death on Mount Shouyang” (the illness of sinking into dead water in Zen) like Boyi and Shuqi. On the other hand, if you lean only toward “establishment” like Taigong Wang, you will be swallowed by the waves of fame, achievements, and differentiation, and you will lose peace.
In short, in the kingdom of each person’s “mind,” Fengxue presented two aspects: the aspect where waves of differentiation arise and act (flourishing and establishing) and the aspect where all waves disappear and return to quietness (perishing and sweeping away). He warned, “You must not lean toward only one of these two.”
Wansong commented, [Gaining it is inherently present] and [Losing it is inherently absent]. This means that the phenomenal world expanding actively by establishing a single particle of dust (gaining) happens because one’s original mind (Buddha-nature) inherently has the function to create all expressions and differentiation (inherently present). On the other hand, being able to erase all differentiation and concepts and become nothing (losing) happens because one’s original mind is also emptiness free from all attachments.
What is Xuedou’s True Intention?: Is there anyone who challenges the balance between the aspect with differentiation and the aspect without differentiation?
Now, here Xuedou held up his staff.
- Staff (柱杖): A stick about as tall as a human, held by monks. Zen monks always carried it with them during their travels.
- Holding up (拈): Presenting or showing something. This word is based on the famous story of holding up a flower and smiling (拈華微笑).
When Xuedou held up his staff, Wansong commented, [Is this establishing or not establishing?]. This means: “Is this action of Xuedou holding up his staff (a single particle of dust) establishing or not establishing?” This behavior of holding up a staff is an action used when explanations with words cannot settle the matter.
For a clear-minded monk, Fengxue’s koan would be solved at this point. However, Xuedou kindly asked a question: “Are there any monks who die together and live together?” In other words, it means: “Is there anyone who challenges this exquisite total dynamic functioning of freely working (全機現) both establishing and not establishing at the same time?” Wansong commented, [I do not say there are none, only that they are few].
My Experience
What Is Right?: Accept Choices Instead Of Correctness
This koan was about challenging the balance between establishing a single particle of dust and not establishing a single particle of dust. In fact, throughout Shoyoroku, in various ways, it is always taught that “responding to each situation immediately is important, and fixed absolute correctness does not exist.” Then, if judgment changes depending on the situation and time, on what basis should we act?
In Zen, when we “respond to the situation on the spot,” it is assumed that we do not put in our own desires or thoughts. However, in society, “the convenience of the leader of a group” is often treated as “correctness,” and the group tends to be managed in a way that each member follows it. Therefore, if the leader is a dangerous person or becomes corrupt, the whole group cannot help but become like that.
Therefore, as an antithesis to this, this blog proposes practicing Zen by yourself without blindly following the convenience of the group. For that purpose, you must discipline yourself and respond to the situation on the spot on your own responsibility.
I once worried whether I should live completely separated from groups that force their own convenience on others. However, since society is built on such systems, doing so would leave me with no choice but to starve to death. Now, by taking responsibility for my choices and maintaining my independence, I am able to blend into society.
Q&A
- Q: Why did Xuedou Chongxian avoid explanations with words and hold up his staff?
- A: Because trying to explain the conflict between "establishing" and "not establishing" by fixing it with words cannot settle the matter. Therefore, he directly showed the state of freely working both at the same time through his own action, and asked, "Are there any monks who challenge this exquisite state?"
Mind Weather before AI comments?