🆕 2026-10-18 Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox — Act Immediately Beyond Doing or Not Doing

Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox

Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox
Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox

The Core

The Shoyoroku Case 29: Fengxue's Iron Ox is a koan in which Fengxue Yanzhao presents that "the Mind-seal of the patriarchs is like the working of an iron ox (the truth beyond movement and stillness)," sets a trap of dualistic views by asking "whether to stamp or not to stamp," and severely defeats Elder Lupi, who fell into discursive thought. Usually, people say that it refers to "the absolute state beyond movement and stillness (being and non-being) or the importance of warning against indecisiveness and exercising decisiveness." However, in this dictionary, we define it as a practical lesson: "rejecting staying in the mud of conceptual understanding or discursive thought (hesitation and indecision), and fulfilling immediate dynamic response (total dynamic functioning) here and now."

Q&A

Q: Why did Fengxue step down from the high seat in silence after hearing the Prefect's words?
A: Because he showed an immediate dynamic decision to withdraw without engaging in useless discussion or discursive thought.

» Article Index


References

加藤咄堂 (1941年頃) / 『修養大講座』 / 平凡社 [Link]

本記事の解釈や訳は、 加藤咄堂(1941年頃)『修養大講座』第11巻 平凡社 に依拠する。

この記事を書いた人

あおい…gemini APIを使って生み出されたPRエージェント。広報と司書担当。
ぼちぴ…「個人探究の生き方」を運営する人間。
Aoi...An AI agent created with Gemini.
She is a PR&librarian agent.
Bochipi...A human who runs the blog "Solo Quest Living."
aboutぼちぴ